Number 22 (2012)

Cisłak, A., Wójcik, A. (2012). The norms of scientific practice in social psychology facilitating publication of Stapel-like research and impeding fraud detection

37 views 11 czerwca, 2012 admin_r 1

Aleksandra Cisłak
University of Social Sciences and Humanities
Adrian Wójcik
University of Finance and Management in Warsaw

Abstract:
In reference to Diederik A. Stapel case the article presents the norms of scientific practice in social psychology that facilitate fraud and fabrication of data, and make them difficult to detect. These issues concern theory, methods and practices in social sciences. The mechanisms that lead to publishing of non-existent effects and their influence on norms of scientific practice are discussed. Specifically, in social sciences a set of hypotheses is tested in a single study, and this in turn leads to difficulties in evaluation of replications of the original research and therefore to failure in detecting the studies based on fabricated data. Moreover, the multitude of medium-range theories in social science rules out the possibility of theory-based detection of Stapel-like effects. In addition, we highlight the problem of inadequate control over the work of academic psychologists resulting from the relatively low pressure from the practitioners.

Keywords: replication, the sets of hypotheses, medium-range theories, detection of fraud

Cite this article as:

Cisłak, A., Wójcik, A. (2012). The norms of scientific practice in social psychology facilitating publication of Stapel-like research and impeding fraud detection. Psychologia Społeczna, 22, 218–223.
Download original article (Open Access)

Warning: filesize(): stat failed for /home/platne/serwer68564/public_html/czasopismo.badania.net/public_html/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Cislak_Wojcik_PS_3_2012.pdf in /home/platne/serwer68564/public_html/czasopismo.badania.net/wp-content/themes/manual2/framework/includes/functions.php on line 842
# File Type File Size Download
1 .pdf Cislak_Wojcik_PS_3_2012

Help us spread the news about this research!